Return to Website

Number Watch Web Forum

This forum is about wrong numbers in science, politics and the media. It respects good science and good English.

Number Watch Web Forum
Start a New Topic 
Where does wind energy come from?

So I was having a conversation with someone about the (doubtless trivial) downwind effect of wind turbines. They thought (ignoring turbulence and other fluid dynamics stuff, which I know nothing about either) the air downwind would be moving more slowly. Essentially that the source of the energy was the veolicty of the air moving past the blades.

Then I thought - if you stuck a turbine in a wind tunnel, blow air through it at a constant mass per time, until you reach equilibrium, what you actually have is higher air pressure ahead of the turbine and lower behind. As a constant mass per time of air has to pass any one point, the lower pressure air must actually be moving faster, and the source of energy is extracted from the "work done on compressing a gas".

Am I wrong or just reinventing old theories?

Re: Where does wind energy come from?

I'll give it a try.

You, indeed, will have a lower pressure downwind, as there is a resistance effect due to the turbine. However, in order to keep a constant mass flow, would mean that you have different densities between both sides of the turbine. Gases are compressible, hence you could, theoretically, keep the same mass, different velocities and different densities.

It is, actually, this density difference that is directly related to the pressure, the one that causes the flow. And given the question you asked I am quite sure this last paragraph is now more than obvious to you.

Now, I am not an expert in fluid dynamics, specially with gases, but this made sense to me.

Re: Where does wind energy come from?

Ultimately wind energy comes from nuclear fusion in the sun.
Warm air becomes less dense and lower pressure, it rises, cooler air flows in to take its place, then the explanation you provided takes over from there.

Well, you did ask where the wind energy comes from, not how a wind turbine works. :)

Nuclear decay in the Earth's core, and nuclear fusion + fission in the sun are the only sources of energy that Earth has, everything else is a derivative. This is also why the widespread adoption of solar power is inevitable, because given enough time (300 years or less) all other sources of power for our current population levels require depleting a finite material fuel resource hundreds of thousands of times faster than it can be regenerated. (Wood is a form of solar power less than 1% efficient.) Ultimately no process on Earth is sustainable indefinitely. When you hear this word "sustainability" being thrown around willy-nilly, one has to question what exact definition is being used. Typically there isn't one, it's just eco-feelgoodery.
Industrial civilisation will live fast and die young, we are just quibbling over exactly how fast and exactly how young.

I figure civilisation is going to die anyway, so we may as well shoot for the stars while we can instead of crippling industry and hugging trees. We don't know if we can leave here, nor how long we will have to live on a polluted planet until we figure it out, so none of the above is any excuse for screwing up our own ecological support systems. We may even figure out how to actually escape the planet in the attempt. Any other course of action is irrational, given physics and earth sciences as we know it, and a will to survive, explore, and prosper.

If it weren't for megalomaniacs and banksters screwing us at every opportunity we might be further along towards peace and (dare I say it) utopia. Anyone who says technology can't solve social problems has underestimated the impact of agriculture and washing machines.

For me, a simple question about wind energy leads to a profound central problem of being human.

Re: Where does wind energy come from?

The turbine operation is basically governed by Bernoulli’s equation. If you do a web search for, say, “wind turbine efficiency” you will find many relevant articles. An interesting outcome is that turbine efficiency cannot exceed a certain limit (the Betz efficiency) which is 0.59.